Sunday, 22 June 2014

Curric and Cheats?

I love the way Rener and Ryron Gracie are setting up their curriculum. It is their intention to organize and codify everything one needs to be a Black Belt, and to teach it all in the most logical order.

They call the first level of material, “Combatives”. This is for beginners, and consists of 36 techniques organized into 23 lessons. The premise is that these 36 techniques will contains 95% of everything needed to defeat an unskilled opponent. At this level the student wears a White Belt as they train through the 23 lessons, from beginning to end, three times each. There is no free sparring at this level.

After the student passes a rigorous exam covering all 36 combative techniques in painful detail, they are awarded a Blue Belt.

Their new belt starts out plain, and as they progress through four levels they are awarded white stripes to adorn their Blue Belt. This is when free sparring, or rolling, begins.

The first level, logically called Blue Belt Stripe One, consists of 60 techniques. It takes a year to a year-and-half to cycle through the curriculum.

Mixed in with all the other new stuff are counters to everything that was learned as a White Belt. At Blue Belt Stripe Two there are 60 more techniques, including counters to everything learned in Blue Belt Stripe One.

This is as far at the Gracie brothers have gotten in releasing their curriculum to date. Rank beyond this is based on attendance, time-in-rank, and general ability.

They get a lot of grief for presenting their material via an online video system, and for doing the testing by having the exam video recorded and submitted to them for evaluation.

I'm a 30 year veteran of traditional Karate, and recently retired from a career as a high school teacher. I can attest to the quality of the program, and to its testing system.

My favorite is the complaint that goes, “somebody could memorize the test material without actually learning the techniques.” If you think so, try it.

Another is the claim that you could get some experienced Jiu-Jitsu guy to take the test for you. Unless he's a student of Ryron and Rener, he won't pass without putting in a lot of work ahead of time.

For example; in the test the candidate can't just do a fine Americana Armlock, he has to do it Rener and Ryron's right way. All of the steps as shown by Rener and Ryron must be there.

He starts from the mount; grabs his partner's wrist with one hand; shoots his other hand underneath as his partner's arm nears the floor; applies pressure as the arm hits the floor; his partner taps.

He just lost 7 points, and he's only half way through a single one of the 36 techniques. This looks like he's on the way to about 500 deductions. The limit for passing is 20. Keep in mind that this is a guy who is doing a fine move, just not a fine Gracie move.

During testing, the techniques are divided into 4 groups, and each group is recorded within a five-minute time limit, and each must be done in a continuous shot. No editing, or the whole thing is rejected.

To cheat on the exam sounds like a lot of work to me.

Let's say you manage to cheat the exam somehow; what do you gain? You've put in a lot of work and ingenuity, and sent the Gracies an $85 exam fee in exchange for a Blue Belt. By walking into any martial arts supply place you can buy a belt for about $10. Why not buy yourself a nice, Black Belt instead?

At the higher levels, the tests for Blue Belt stripes are much, much harder. I spent a year and a half learning the precisely correct Gracie material, and it still took me a couple of months of cramming to get ready and to perform the exam.

I've earned a University degree, and have a Black Belt in Shotokan Karate, and my Gracie Blue Belt Stripe One exam is harder than any test I've ever taken. It was harder than any five exams I've ever done put together.

If somehow, by some miracle you manage to cheat through all four levels of Blue Belt, you're still just a Blue Belt. These are common as dirt, and really carry no status at all. Purple really means something, and is sort of the equivalent of a Black Belt in other arts.

Evaluation for Purple Belt, and then again at Brown Belt, and again at Black require in-person evaluation by Rener or Royce Gracie. How are you going to fake that?





No comments:

Post a Comment